Valentine’s Day 2025: Best Romantic Restaurants on Long Island

Finding the perfect dinner spot for Valentine’s Day can be a struggle, but luckily Long Island has a variety of romantic options to choose from. This is the holiday to enjoy an intimate dinner with your special someone that has both a delicious menu and substantial hospitality. Here are 8 of the best Long Island restaurants to try this Valentine’s Day.

Limani, Roslyn

Located in Roslyn, New York is Limani, a luxurious Mediterranean seafood restaurant that focuses on traditional Greek specialties. Their vast dinner menu offers a plethora of Mediterranean fare, along with a prix-fixe menu of $44 per person. They also offer a large list of wines from various countries to pair with their dishes. Limani’s interior features a modern and classy ambience, perfect for a romantic dinner.

Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington

In Huntington you can find Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, with fare from both land and sea. This Valentine’s Day, they are hosting a $125++ prix-fixe menu for guests to enjoy. Located on the waterfront, Prime offers stunning scenic ocean views for a romantic date night. The interior offers a modern coastal vibe and ambient lighting to set the mood. For a luxurious Valentine’s Day dinner, Prime is the spot to be.

Calissa Hamptons, Water Mill

Calissa Hamptons is a chic Greek restaurant located in Water Mill, New York. Their menu focuses on classic recipes from the Aegean Islands crafted with the freshest quality ingredients. Their full menu will be offered on Valentine’s Day, along with additional seasonal specials. Calissa’s cozy atmosphere is an ideal spot for an intimate dinner. Their extensive wine list has been awarded The Award of Excellence from Wine Spectator, and pairs perfectly with their dishes.

Bell & Anchor, Sag Harbor

Bell & Anchor located in Sag Harbor offers an upscale New American dining experience. The restaurant pulls inspiration from its regions rich culture and history with locally sourced seafood and other ingredients. With stunning waterfront views and a welcoming atmosphere, Bell & Anchor is the ideal spot for a romantic evening. From February 12^th-14^th, they will be holding a Valentine’s Day special with an a la carte menu. The special also offers $2 Montauk Pearl Oysters and $15 glasses of champagne.

Coco Bistro Kitchen & Lounge, Smithtown

Coco Bistro Kitchen & Lounge in Smithtown is known for having Long Island’s best Cuban cuisine. The restaurant features a tropical interior covered with greenery and palm trees. This Valentine’s Day, Coco Bistro is offering a $75 prix-fixe menu per person that features classic Latin flavors. Along with a delicious menu, the restaurant is also a great spot for good music and lively energy. At night, Coco Bistro turns into an upbeat lounge perfect for a night of dancing with your Valentine.

North Fork Table & Inn, Southold

For a luxurious date night, North Fork Table & Inn in Southold is the place to go. As one of the original farm-to-table restaurants, this dining experience is a staple of Long Island. The restaurant is housed in a historic countryside home that has been remodeled to create a warm and inviting establishment. For this romantic holiday, North Fork is offering a $115 three course menu along with a $92 wine pairing. With exceptional hospitality and a delectable menu, this is an ideal spot to spend this Valentine’s Day.

Stone Creek Inn, East Quogue

Stone Creek Inn in East Quogue has brought an unforgettable dining experience to the Hamptons since 1996. Their exquisite French cuisine offers flavors from Southwest France with fresh ingredients. Their interior features warm lighting and tasteful décor for guests to feel welcomed. This Valentine’s Day, Stone Creek Inn is offering an a la carte menu featuring some of their best menu items. Housed in a stunning restored historic building, this is the best spot to bring your Valentine for a romantic evening.

Primi Italian Steakhouse, West Islip

For a romantic steak dinner, head over to the luxurious Primi Italian Steakhouse in West Islip. This restaurant features a vast dining room with beautiful chandeliers and décor that creates an elegant dining experience. For Valentine’s Day, Primi is offering a $125 prix-fixe menu with some of their best flavors. This is a perfect spot for an intimate dinner with excellent hospitality and a delicious meal. Reservations fill up fast, so be sure to reserve your romantic night out.