Cuisine can define the success of any event. A thoughtfully curated menu has the power to transform even the simplest gathering into an extraordinary experience, while a poor culinary offering can leave a lasting impression—for all the wrong reasons. In this feature, we unveil the 10 premier catering halls in the Long Island area, each poised to elevate your special occasions with exceptional food, service, and ambiance.
Peconic Bay Yacht Club
Photo by: Kaitlyn Ferris Photography
Located in Southold on the North Fork of Long Island, the Peconic Bay Yacht Club offers a serene waterfront setting with sweeping views of Peconic Bay. The venue combines modern coastal elegance with nautical charm, featuring a beautifully appointed indoor ballroom, an expansive outdoor terrace and a private marina. Perfect for both intimate gatherings and grand celebrations, it delivers exclusivity and tranquility. The in-house catering emphasizes fresh, local ingredients, including seafood-forward menus, seasonal farm-to-table dishes and curated wine selections from nearby vineyards. Cocktail hour on the lawn, followed by dinner overlooking the water, creates a quintessential East End experience.
Image Credit: Okeha Castle
The very inspiration for F. Scott Fitzgerald’s Great Gatsby mansion sits on the highest point of Long Island. With 32 guest suites, grand ballrooms and sweeping gardens, patrons get to experience true luxury here. The in-house catering at Okeha includes delectable hors d’oeuvres, delicious entrees, a decadent dessert cafe and customized wedding cakes. Signature cocktails, top-tier bar and white-glove service enrich the Castle experience.
Image Credit: The Crest Hallow Country Club
Crest Hollow offers a variety of modern, elegant ballrooms that can be customized for everything from intimate weddings to large corporate galas. The upscale yet versatile event space features a South Beach–inspired outdoor setting, complete with tropical landscaping, waterfalls and a poolside area ideal for cocktail hours or open-air ceremonies. Their exceptional catering includes a wide range of globally inspired cuisines. From traditional Italian and American dishes to specialty menus tailored to Indian, Glatt Kosher, and Latin cultures. Every dish is made on-site with fresh, high-quality ingredients, ensuring that guests enjoy a top-tier dining experience that matches the venue’s visual elegance.
Leonard’s Palazzo
Image Credit: Leonard’s Palazzo
Located in Great Neck, Leonard’s Palazzo is renowned for its striking interiors, featuring crystal chandeliers, grand staircases and marble floors, making it a popular choice for elegant, large-scale events. The venue features multiple ballrooms and flexible layouts, making it ideal for weddings, galas and cultural celebrations. Leonard’s in-house catering boasts an extensive selection of hors d’oeuvres, plated dinners and specialty desserts. From Mediterranean-inspired dishes to lavish carving stations, the culinary team is known for both quality and presentation. Custom bar service and attentive waitstaff complete the upscale experience.
Sand Castle Venue
Image Credit: Sand Castle Venu
A European-inspired estate in Franklin Square, Sand Castle delivers a fairytale setting with five acres of landscaped gardens, ornate interiors and a romantic ambiance. The venue is designed to host only one event at a time, ensuring privacy and personalized service. Their award-winning catering offers a diverse range of gourmet options, from classic continental dishes to contemporary fusion menus. Elegant cocktail stations, formal plated meals and custom dessert options are all prepared in-house by expert chefs, making food one of Sand Castle’s standout features.
Image Credit: The Inn at New Hyde Park
Combining old-world charm with modern luxury, The Inn at New Hyde Park features lavish ballrooms, elegant garden courtyards, and vintage-inspired décor. With a tradition of hospitality dating back to 1938, the venue excels in executing timeless, upscale events. The catering team provides a refined culinary experience, offering multi-course meals crafted from fresh, seasonal ingredients. Menu offerings include gourmet hors d’oeuvres, sophisticated entrées and artisanal dessert displays, all paired with attentive service and premium beverage options.
Floral Terrace
Image Credit: Floral Terrace
Nestled in Floral Park, this venue is a former theater transformed into an ornate ballroom with vaulted ceilings, glowing chandeliers, and elegant mezzanine levels. The space is especially popular for its romantic ambiance and seamless blend of historic charm and contemporary flair. The catering at Floral Terrace is both flexible and upscale, offering plated meals, buffet-style dinners, and international cuisine options to match the client’s vision. Their culinary staff works closely with guests to design custom menus featuring everything from gourmet entrees to curated dessert bars.
Sea Cliff Manor
Image Credit: Sea Cliff Manor
Overlooking the Long Island Sound, Sea Cliff Manor offers a stunning waterfront backdrop with classic mansion-style architecture and elegant indoor and outdoor event spaces. With ivy-covered stone walls and a wraparound veranda, the venue evokes timeless sophistication. Their catering program focuses on elevated cuisine using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Guests enjoy handcrafted hors d’oeuvres, beautifully plated main courses and decadent desserts, all served with warm, attentive service in a serene coastal setting.
NYIT de Seversky Mansion
Image Credit: NYIT de Seversky Mansion
A grand estate located on the NYIT campus in Old Westbury, de Seversky Mansion is a Georgian-style mansion that brings historical elegance and exclusivity to every event. The mansion hosts only one event per day, offering access to its marble halls, garden terraces and richly appointed rooms. Its catering service is chef-driven, offering seasonal menus tailored to each client’s taste, including plated multi-course meals, fine wine pairings and signature cocktails. With a focus on presentation and flavor, the cuisine matches the mansion’s upscale aesthetic.
Chateau at Coindre Hall
Image Credit: Chateau at Coindre Hall
Overlooking the serene Huntington Harbor, Chateau at Coindre Hall offers a storybook setting inspired by 13th-century French architecture. This historic waterfront mansion features stone archways, turrets, and grand staircases, creating an atmosphere of timeless elegance. With indoor ballrooms rich in Old World charm and outdoor terraces perfect for sunset views, the venue is ideal for luxurious, intimate affairs. The in-house catering delivers a refined culinary experience, offering gourmet hors d’oeuvres, elegantly plated entrées and decadent desserts. Menus are fully customizable, blending classic European flavors with seasonal, locally sourced ingredients, all served with impeccable attention to detail.
For more articles like this visit https://vuelongisland.com/best-boutique-hotels-in-the-hamptons-for-a-spring-getaway/
MORE Lifestyle STORIES
Get an inside vue on the latest in luxury. You heard it here first.